By Paul Redding
This 2007 publication examines the chances for the rehabilitation of Hegelian inspiration inside of analytic philosophy. From its inception, the analytic culture has as a rule approved Bertrand Russell's adversarial dismissal of the idealists, in keeping with the declare that their metaphysical perspectives have been irretrievably corrupted by way of the defective common sense that trained them. those assumptions are challenged via the paintings of such analytic philosophers as John McDowell and Robert Brandom, who, whereas contributing to center components of the analytic flow, however have present in Hegel refined rules which are capable of deal with difficulties which nonetheless hang-out the analytic culture after 100 years. Paul Redding strains the implications of the displacement of the common sense presupposed by means of Kant and Hegel through glossy post-Fregean good judgment, and examines the advancements inside of twentieth-century analytic philosophy that have made attainable an analytic re-engagement with a formerly brushed aside philosophical culture.
Read or Download Analytic Philosophy and the Return of Hegelian Thought (Modern European Philosophy) PDF
Best philosophy books
On the center of a few of the main influential strands of philosophical, political, and aesthetic modernism lies the conviction that modernity is essentially nihilistic. This booklet bargains a wide-ranging severe heritage of the concept that of nihilism from its origins in French innovative discourse to its position in contemporary theorizations of the postmodern.
This inaugural-and all new-Tarcher Cornerstone variation offers a stunningly correct and trustworthy translation of the options and aphorisms of the Stoic thinker and Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius, accurately putting the philosopher-king's writings in the vein of the world's nice non secular and moral traditions.
The Routledge Guidebook to Heidegger's Being and Time examines the paintings of 1 of the main arguable thinkers of the 20 th century. Heidegger's writings are notoriously tricky, requiring cautious interpreting. This publication analyses his first significant booklet, "Being and Time," which to today continues to be his so much influential paintings.
- All Gall is Divided: The Aphorisms of a Legendary Iconoclast
- The Way Back to Paradise: Restoring the Balance Between Magic and Reason
- The Ethnological Notebooks of Karl Marx: Studies of Morgan, Phear, Maine, Lubbock
- The Cambridge Companion to Seneca (Cambridge Companions to Literature)
Additional info for Analytic Philosophy and the Return of Hegelian Thought (Modern European Philosophy)
On the other hand, Rorty’s book clearly touched a nerve, and to a considerable extent polarized the Anglophone philosophy profession, and similarly McDowell’s has not entirely escaped the negative reaction that Rorty’s attracted. From the orthodox analytic point of view, perhaps the claim most difficult to digest in the whole book is a remark, made almost as an aside at the end of Lecture II, where McDowell appeals to Hegel as 1 2 Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979. : Harvard University Press.
46 For McDowell this latter condition implied that there was a grain of truth in those theories of sense that, like Frege’s, identified the sense of a proper name with some definite description picking out the name’s bearer, in that ‘a person who knows the sense of a name must have some beliefs about its bearer’. However, that in itself did not warrant the demand that such descriptions uniquely identify the referent. 47 McDowell envisaged such a revisionary view of sense as having a variety of consequences, one concerning how to think of ‘empty 45 46 47 McDowell, ‘On Sense and Reference of a Proper Name’, p.
The best way I know to work into this different conception of what is natural is by reflecting on Aristotle’s ethics’. , p. 78. 28 ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY AND THE RETURN OF HEGELIAN THOUGHT object of McDowell’s ‘Hegelian’-styled critique, a more careful reading suggests that it is rather a more general philosophical doctrine, better identified in terms of central elements of Platonism, that emerges as the real object of McDowell’s criticism. In fact, one of McDowell’s first published papers linked Russell, who, in the guise of the proponent of sense-data may be regarded as a prototypical advocate of ‘givenness’ in modern analytic philosophy, with Plato.